Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Operating safely, ethically and legally

Experiential AI & Ecology
Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Steve Bullock · University of Bristol

Imageomics Institute and ABC Global Center
steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Every capability is a responsibility

HEIGHT ABOVE GROUND Satellites~500 km · whole regions, repeat visits Crewed aircraft~1 km · censuses, lidar Drones~100 m · centimetre imagery Camera traps & acoustics~1 m · always on, for months eDNAin the water and soil

…and the AI that turns it all
into counts and maps.

Three lenses:

Safenobody, human or animal, gets hurt

Ethicalwhat you should do, not just what you can

Legalthe rules where and how you work

Tuia, Remote sensing crash course · Tuia et al. 2022, Nat Commun · Kitzes et al. 2025, MEE

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Safe is not the same as compliant

Safety = reducing the actual risk of harm

Compliance = following the applicable rules, standards and procedures

You can be compliant but unsafe, if the rules are incomplete or applied mechanically.

You can be safe but not compliant, if you break a formal requirement even when the real risk is low.

Safe Legal Ethical Aim here

HSE: managing risks and risk assessment · Reading: Safe, ethical, legal

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Safe

Nobody, human or animal, gets hurt

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Assess the risk before you go

1 · Hazardspeople, animals, kit, environment
2 · Harmwho could be hurt, how likely, how badly?
3 · Controlswork down the hierarchy
4 · Plan Bemergencies, comms, check-ins
5 · Reviewon site, and after near misses

Use your institution's fieldwork risk assessment and the course's field safety plan. They're there to make you think, not to collect signatures.

Air riskwhat else is in the sky? Ground riskwho and what is underneath?

USHA/UCEA, Health and safety in fieldwork · Course field safety plan · EASA Specific category and SORA

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

The hierarchy of controls

MOST EFFECTIVE LEAST EFFECTIVE Eliminate Substitute Engineer Procedures PPE Don't fly over people; survey from the boat A lighter drone; a camera trap, not a hide Geofence, prop guards, parachute Checklists, briefings, a visual observer Hi-vis, helmet, LiPo-safe bag

Principles of prevention, MHSWR 1999 Sch. 1 · HSE: risk assessment

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Procedures, every time

Two golden rules

1
Develop and use procedures and checklists. Otherwise, at some point, you will forget something critical.
2
Never have the propellers fitted and the battery connected at the same time, unless you are about to take off.

Field lessons

  • Do your homework, with local people and institutions
  • Do the paperwork before you go
  • Recce the site if you can
  • Clear test plan; beware scope creep
  • Plan rest days
  • Don't count on one deployment
  • Keep structured records

CAA Drone Code · FAA: Recreational flyers

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Who else is at risk?

The animals

Drones can disturb wildlife in ways a person on foot would not: species, altitude, approach and noise all matter.

People nearby

Communities, landowners, other airspace users, your own team.

People downstream

If a detector misses a poacher or overcounts a population, someone acts on a wrong answer.

Who checks the model?

Hodgson & Koh 2016, Curr Biol · Mulero-Pázmány et al. 2017, PLOS ONE · Tuia et al. 2022

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Ethical

What you should do, not only what you can

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Technology is not ethically neutral

Built to…
…but also
A thermal drone finds animals at night
→
finds people
Camera traps record wildlife
→
photograph hunters, herders and villagers
Acoustic recorders capture birdsong
→
capture speech
Precise locations support conservation
→
guide poachers and collectors
50 cm imagery resolves one animal
→
resolves homes and vehicles
An open model tracks animals
→
tracks people

Start with Sandbrook et al. (2021): principles for socially responsible conservation monitoring.

Sandbrook et al. 2021 · Sandbrook 2015 · Sharma et al. 2020 · Cretois et al. 2022 · Lindenmayer & Scheele 2017 · Millner 2020

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Design values in from the start

Value-sensitive design (Friedman & Hendry 2019): who are the stakeholders, which values are at stake, and how do you build them in?

Privacy
Animal welfare
SPECIFY
JUSTIFY
Value
Privacy of people near the study site
Wildlife isn't harmed or disturbed
Norm
People captured by accident aren't identifiable
Approaches stay below a disturbance threshold
Design requirement
Detect and blur people on the device, before storage; geofence villages
Minimum altitude and approach rules; abort on a behavioural response

Friedman & Hendry 2019, Value Sensitive Design · van de Poel 2013, Translating values into design requirements

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Capability caution

CAPABILITYGOOD ENOUGH FOR THE MISSION: STOPMAXIMUM
neededmisuse risk grows, mission gains little

Ask of each capability: do we need it, and how could it be misused?

  1. Context of use: where, by whom, under whose rules?
  2. Privacy: what does it record that it doesn't need?
  3. Jobs and human skills: whose work does it change or replace?
  4. Safety, security and misuse: who could use it, or its data, for harm?
  5. The future: what will it make possible in ten years, in other hands?

Cawthorne & Devos 2020, Capability caution in UAV design · Stilgoe et al. 2013, Responsible innovation

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Share data fairly

FAIR is about data

FFindable
AAccessible
IInteroperable
RReusable

CARE is about people

CCollective benefit
AAuthority to control
RResponsibility
EEthics
  • Who benefits from your data and models?
  • Do the communities where you collect gain anything?
  • Do sensitive species' locations need generalising before release?
  • Does your work need ethics review? Animals, people (even by accident), fieldwork abroad, eDNA, Indigenous lands or data

GO FAIR · GIDA CARE principles · Chapman 2020, GBIF sensitive species data · Wildlife Insights FAQ

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Legal

Mostly drones: flying puts you under aviation law everywhere

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

UK and EU: risk-based, not purpose-based

Correct as of October 2026, and my interpretation. Not legal advice. It's up to you to operate within the requirements of where you fly and of your own institution.
Openlow risk: registration and an online test
Specificoperational authorisation, from a risk assessment
Certifiedregulated like crewed aviation
LOWER RISKHIGHER RISK

No recreational/commercial distinction. Same drone, same place, same rules.

UK (CAA): free Flyer ID from 100 g since January 2026, plus an Operator ID

EU (EASA): register and pass the free A1/A3 online exam with your national authority

CAA: Flyer ID · CAA: Drone Code updates · EASA: Open category · EASA: national authorities

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

US: Part 107 or the recreational exception

NOYESYESNO Flying strictlyfor fun? Research flown by auniversity, as the university? Part 10714 CFR 107 Recreational exception49 U.S.C. § 44809 TRUST, registration, line of sight,400 ft, airspace authorisation,CBO safety guidelines: all of them May count as recreationalP.L. 116-283 §10002 (2021) Within every § 44809 limit. Manyuniversities require Part 107 anyway:ask yours Most research flying:companies, agencies,NGOs, and you as anindividual

49 U.S.C. § 44809 · P.L. 116-283 §10002 · 14 CFR Part 107 · FAA: Educational users · FAA: TRUST

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Check before you fly, and beyond aviation

Everywhere: some countries restrict drones heavily, need import permits, or ban them in protected areas. Check the aviation authority, the protected-area authority and local partners well before you travel, and an airspace map on the day.

Privacy

People in images and audio are personal data

Wildlife

Disturbance offences, research permits

Genetic resources

eDNA and the Nagoya Protocol

Export controls

Thermal cameras, some drones and software

Data licences

Commercial imagery terms

ICO: drones · EASA: drones and privacy · Nagoya Protocol · EU dual-use Reg. 2021/821 · FAA B4UFLY

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

Before the live session

1

Drone basics

~30 min, if you might fly

UK Flyer ID · EU A1/A3 · US TRUST

Explore an airspace map for home and your field site

2

Read

~10 min

Safe, ethical, legal: with links to go further

3

Capability audit canvas

~20 min

Fill in parts 1–5 for your own system and upload it

Part 6, the red team, happens live

Be specific: "thermal camera at 120 m picks out people in the village by the reserve" beats "privacy".

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026 · Reading · Canvas (.docx)

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026
Experiential AI & Ecology · Module 3: multimodal ecosystem sensing

See you in the live session

steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026

Imageomics Institute and ABC Global Center
steve.engineer/teaching/imageomics2026

Hi, I'm Steve Bullock from the University of Bristol and Bristol Flight Lab. This is a ten-minute introduction to my part of the live session: how to use the sensing technologies Justin and Devis are talking about safely, ethically and legally. It goes with the short reading and the capability audit canvas on the course page.

Devis's crash course takes you from satellites down to a drone over a herd. Add camera traps, acoustics, eDNA and the models, and it's an extraordinary toolkit. Every capability in it is also a responsibility. I'll look through three lenses: safe, ethical, legal.

Safety and compliance overlap, but they aren't the same. If you only tick boxes you can still hurt someone; if you only trust your own judgement you can still end up in serious trouble. And neither guarantees you're doing the right thing. Aim for the middle.

Use your institution's fieldwork risk assessment, and the course's own field safety plan. The steps are the same everywhere: hazards, harm, controls, plan B, review. For drones beyond the lowest-risk category, Europe and the UK use SORA, which splits ground risk from air risk. Even if you never write one, that split is a useful way to think about any flight.

When you choose controls, work from the top. Removing the hazard beats everything else; personal protective equipment is the last resort, not the first. The examples on the right are from drone and fieldwork planning.

Two rules every drone lab learns the hard way: use procedures and checklists, and never have the props on and the battery connected unless you're about to fly. The field lessons apply just as much to a camera-trap grid or an acoustic array: work with local people, do the paperwork early, plan rest, and expect to go back more than once.

Your risk assessment should include the animals: there's good evidence on drone disturbance and good practice for reducing it. And it should include people downstream of your outputs. Automated pipelines make mistakes at scale. Who checks?

Design choices decide what a system can do, and to whom: which sensors, how much autonomy, what data you keep, what you release. Every one of these is a real example, and conservation technology has been used against the communities who live where it's deployed. Sandbrook and colleagues' 2021 principles are the best single place to start.

Value-sensitive design treats ethics as part of design, not a form at the end. The values hierarchy turns an abstract value into a norm, and the norm into something you can build or test. Read it top-down to specify, or bottom-up to justify why a requirement exists.

Capability caution is the design habit that goes with it: an alternative to maximising every capability. Set "good enough" for the mission, then stop. These five principles are the questions the canvas asks you to work through for your own system.

Open data makes science better, but open isn't always fair or safe. FAIR and CARE work together. GBIF has good guidance on generalising sensitive species locations. And find your ethics committee early: approval can take months.

The UK and EU regulate by risk, not by why you fly, so these first qualifications are a real first step for research. The UK rules changed in January: you now need a Flyer ID from 100 grams. In the EU, use your national authority's official site; there are fake licence sites.

The US does distinguish by purpose. Training courses, Embry-Riddle's included, say if it isn't for fun you need Part 107, and for most people that's right. But since 2021 the law has counted university research as recreational, within all the recreational limits. It doesn't cover companies, agencies or NGOs, and many universities require Part 107 anyway.

Drones are where the law is most visible, but these apply to every sensor. Notice how many of them are about data: privacy, sensitive locations, licences. That's where the AI side of this course meets the law.

Three things before the live session, all linked from the course page. In the session you'll swap canvases with a partner and red-team each other's: find the worst plausible misuse of their system, then decide what you'd change in your own. See you there.